John Carter

For me, the value question comes down to how filling the sandwich feels for the price, not just the menu number alone. Popeyes usually wins that test for me because the fillet is larger and crunchier, even though I still respect Chick-fil-A for consistency and service. The gap in the table above is hard to ignore when you are buying for more than one person, since those small savings add up quickly. Timing matters too, because a weekday deal can change the whole calculation if you plan around it. I would check the popeyes current specials before deciding, then compare the total meal cost at your local restaurant.